Happy February! If you have no interest in reigniting your observance of Black History Month, read on for tips on how to continue doing the same tired thing every year.

1. Definitely put together a display for Black History Month and then never again feature black authors or stories at any other time throughout the year.
While Black History Month is a wonderful time to celebrate the contributions of African Americans to literature, history, politics, and culture, sometimes it’s used as a crutch to avoid promoting these individuals and these stories for the rest of the year. And while booktalking and displaying people by all races and ethnicities is something to be done year-round, ask yourself if you are integrating these books into general displays or if your habit is to always mention that an author or character is black, instead of focusing on the vampire romance or the great writing or the hilarious flying panda bear, you’re not going to get the circulation you want. And you’re being unfair to the book. White authors are recognized for their stories, not their identities. Give that same courtesy to everyone else.

2. Do not take this time to audit your collection and your own reading choices to see if your understanding of African Americans in literature is limited to historical fiction and biographies.
While we should never stop teaching about slavery and civil rights, we do a disservice to readers of all backgrounds when these are the only types of books with black characters that we expose them to. You might have noticed that black people exist today, too! And while race informs and shapes every person of color’s life, we also get in fights with our friends, need a date to prom, and have to battle evil wizards like white characters get to do in fiction. Go out of your way to find contemporary realistic fiction, science fiction, and fantasy with black characters or inspired by African mythology or folktales. Authors like Jacqueline Woodson, Walter Dean Myers, and Angela Johnson are must-haves. Ursula K. Le Guin’s Earthsea series stars a black character. And for perspectives and booklists on people of color in speculative fiction, Bitch Magazine‘s series on Girls of Color in Dystopia is a great starting point, and of course, everyone should be reading Cindy Pon and Malinda Lo’s Diversity in YA.

3. Absolutely ignore Afro-Latinos and the African continent. Only acknowledge American-born blacks descended from slaves.
Not all black people identify as “African American,” because race and ethnicity are not the same. There are first generation Americans with parents from Nigeria. Some black families trace many generations back to Latin America and have no felt connection with the African continent. There are people of African descent who speak Spanish, Portuguese, or French. There are new Americans who are refugees from Sudan. There are mixed race celebrities you never knew were part black. Dig into your collection for literature, poetry and history from places steeped in black culture, like Cuba, Brazil, and the Dominican Republic. Pull out some memoirs by immigrants and refugees like Ishmael Beah. Even during slavery, there were freeborn blacks living in the North and the South. There is a world beyond the usual, and even though this month may only be observed in the United States and Canada (the UK has an observance in October), that doesn’t mean our worldview should be so limited.

4. Display only the names that everyone will recognize and the movements everyone is strongly aligned with. Never be a little polarizing or provoke debate or discussion. New perspectives are bad.
Martin Luther King, Jr.; Toni Morrison; Jackie Robinson; Barack Obama; Oprah Winfrey; Langston Hughes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. How about Malcolm X; Alice Walker; Satchel Paige; George Washington Carver; Soledad O’Brien? Getting better. Or dig in even more. Philippa Duke Schuyler; Rebecca Walker; Sam Cooke; Marcus Samuelsson; Fran Ross; Helen Oyeyemi; Bessie Coleman; Josephine Baker; Lewis Latimer; Madame C.J. Walker; Nicolás Guillén… Do you know all of those names? There is always someone new to discover.

5. Make a point of implying that black history is finished and doesn’t continue to shape America. Never highlight living people or contemporary issues.
I think that says it all.

While Black History Month is just as problematic as it is wonderful, there are plenty of ways to shake things up and make observing it feel fresh and new once again, whatever your opinion of it.

About Hannah Gómez

School librarian in Northern California. MA children's literature, MS library and information science (Simmons College). Sometime scholar, sometime reviewer, sometime creative writer, always media-obsessed.

8 Thoughts on “How to Have the Same Old, Same Old Black History Month

  1. THANK YOU, Hannah. This is fantastic. Have you, by any chance, seen what the Evanston Public Library is doing this year? http://www.epl.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=section&layout=blog&id=24&Itemid=806

  2. Wow, that’s a great initiative! I especially like the idea of their program about The Help. Something like that is sorely needed.

  3. At the age of 50, this is only my third time in life responding to a blog or posting a comment to any website. When I first read the title of the blog I was highly offended and as I continued to read the comments I was slightly a little less offended. However, it was pressed upon me for three days to make a comment so here goes.
    I do not believe you intended to be offensive in this blog but in actuality it is offensive.
    If you research and understand why and how February came to be recognized as Black History Month, you will not make such comments as in # 1, 3,4 & 5.
    Essentially, BHM was rallied for and established because contributions of Black Americans were often not included in white history books.
    Here are just a few things I want to point out about your blog.
    – to inform readers to never again feature Black authors anytime during the year is simply wrong. Black Americans as well as all cultures in America continue to make contributions to this country all year round. To try and limit Black Americans to only 28 days is not correct. If excuse me, when a person makes a contribution to better USA whether black or any other race it should be recognized. The last part of your #1 statement is not necessary.
    – history has taught us any person mixed with a single drop of black blood was considered black and lets not forget there was a time when America did not refer to blacks as blacks but were referred to as …
    – #4 contradicts itself. First you say new perspectives are bad but you end by saying there is always something new to discover. ??? I’m confused!
    – black history will never be finished; daily people make contributions to America, some of the people are black and some are not. Do not limit the contributions of black Americans by a date.
    As you research the origins of BHM you will find many reasons why there was such a push to get it established; one being history has taught people blacks were dumb, unlearned and were only smart enough to be maids or porters.
    I hope I have enlighten you somewhat and maybe next time you can use this platform to truly represent Black History and not a platform to continue to give rise to the “problematic” issues that can plague it.

    • Al, are you familiar with satire?

      • Yes, I am and thank you for the response. Per dictionary.com it means to ridicule, sarcasm, the use of irony – more simply put to make fun of. BHM is not a joke to make fun of.

        Your response is surprising. And to think you are representing a division of ALA is appalling.

        • Then you don’t actually understand satire. The point of this post is to criticize the usual practices when it comes to Black History Month (the stuff in the bold). The rest are the things you should do instead.

  4. Thanks for this post Hannah, I agree with you 100%. In my middle school library display I don’t include any books on slavery or civil rights. My books showcase African American achievements in the arts, science, and government, both historical and contemporary. As you conclude, if we fail to broaden the discussion we imply that once you know Rosa Parks, Harriet Tubman and Dr.King, there’s nothing else to talk about.

Post Navigation